Would you rather work from an office or remotely?
When was work in an office anything other than remote! Yes? No?, or missing the point!

Whilst toying with this topic I thought my views on the matter would take me into exploration of the reduced world implied by the question, where the only choice posed to anyone answering is to consider work as is between performing it ‘remotely ‘ or ‘in an office’. I will come to these words. After all, I get used to reverting to the origins and history of English words, when stuck for a topic, but often find that in doing so it opens up huge issues of social attitude to the issues to which words refer us.
This was more common in the past than in the current climate of thinking, which does its best to abolish the history of everything, words included,in its hubris that being present in the current moment is all that matters. That idea struck John Berger who from the time he moved into a community in Quincy France, always carried round a pocket knife, indicative of the beauty attached to the instruments of work, appreciate through every sence including touch. Work got you nearer to the life of the coomunity, But ‘work’ for a long time had a different history as a word and thirteen years ago, Jeremy Seabrok – of the generation following Berger, Raymond Williams (themselves following on from Richard Hoggart) – wrote a fascinating piece on the meaning of ‘work’ and ‘labour’ for The Guardian, based on etymological speculation of which I quote the largest part below:
The etymology of all the words for “work” in European languages suggests work as coercion, certainly not for the prosperity of the worker, but as a fulfilment of human destiny. Ecclesiastes 3:22 declares: “There is nothing better than that a man should rejoice in his own works; for that is his portion.” Words indicating labour in most European languages originate in an imagery of compulsion, torment, affliction and persecution. The French word travail (and Spanish trabajo), like its English equivalent, are derived from the Latin trepaliare – to torture, to inflict suffering or agony. The word peine, meaning penalty or punishment, also is used to signify arduous labour, something accomplished with great effort. The German Arbeit suggests effort, hardship and suffering; it is cognate with the Slavonic rabota (from which English derives “robot”), a word meaning corvee, forced or serf labour. In romance languages, words from the Latin laborare have come to mean ploughing or tilling the earth, although in Italian, lavoro also means work in general. The Latin meaning was anything accomplished with difficulty and struggle.
The English “work” has an Indo-European stem werg-, via Greek ergon, meaning deed or action without punitive connotations; and Latin urgere, to press, bear down upon or compel. It is cognate with Gothic wrikan, to persecute, and Old English wrecan. Thus, in the word “work”, violence is latent, and it appears in the form wreak, when we speak of wreaking havoc or vengeance. “Toil” derives from Old French, meaning argument or dispute, fight and struggle.
Work was compulsion and punishment, an existential affliction which promised neither wellbeing nor even an assured sustenance. Traces of this more ancient lineage are present in many Biblical references. “In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread,” declares the Book of Genesis; while another axiom much favoured by the taskmasters of the poor is from 2 Thessalonians 3:10: “This we commanded you, that if any would not work, neither should he eat.” The Book of Proverbs is particularly rich in evoking the perils of idleness and sloth. “Through sloth the roof sinks in, and through indolence the house leaks.” “Love not sleep, lest you come to poverty”; “Like vinegar to the teeth and smoke to the eyes, so is the sluggard to those who send him”; “Slothfulness casts into a deep sleep and an idle person will suffer hunger.” [1]
How much of this association to ‘pain’ translated to the notion of ‘office work’. This is especially the case in terms of the root of the word ‘office’ which derived from the nature of ‘service’ but not of torture and often equate with a positive sense of status, or of work conceived of as inseparable from a certain status of being. Try the Online Etymological Dictionary for instance, where there is an old link of ‘duty to do work’ in the origuinal Latin but bound by the 13th Century in European lnguages to some service related to religious or secular power hierarchies :
office (n.): mid-13c., “a post in government or administration, an employment to which certain duties are attached, secular position of authority or responsibility,” from Anglo-French and Old French ofice “place or function; divine service” (12c. in Old French) and directly from Latin officium “a service, kindness, favor; an obligatory service, official duty, function, business; ceremonial observance” (in Medieval Latin, “church service”).
The Latin word was contracted from opificium, literally “work-doing,” from ops (genitive opis) “power, might, abundance, means” (related to opus “work,” from PIE root *op- “to work, produce in abundance”) + combining form of facere “to make, to do” (from PIE root *dhe- “to set, put”).
Of ecclesiastical positions from late 14c. From c. 1300 as “official employment” in general, also “ecclesiastical service or mass; the prescribed order and form of church services.” Meaning “building or room for conducting business” is from late 14c. Meaning “a government or civic department” is from mid-15c. From 1727 as “a privy.”
[also …]
ex officio : Latin, “in discharge of one’s duties,” literally “out of duty,” from ex “out of” (see ex-) + officio, ablative of officium “duty” (see office). (Latin, “in discharge of one’s duties,” literally “out of duty,” from ex “out of” (see ex-) + officio, ablative of officium “duty” (see office)).
In my youth in the 1960s, ‘office-work’ was still seen by parents who did work with their hands (my mother in a mill, my father as a decorator) office-work was seen as a step above our origins. They sought from an acquaintance who owned an engineering firm that he pledge for me a post as an office-trainee, a way out of drudgery as they saw it and a rise in status, and perhaps class. It was the history in those two words that allowed such a belief. Office-work was soft. It’s not a view helt today but there is a notion that it is not substantially a kind of work involving direct contact with either the product or service being made or organised. It is ‘at a remove’. In a sense, its value was that it was ‘remote’ froim the severe sense of work as a kind of punishment. Covid lockdowns introduced widespread use of office workers working remotely, but essentially doing the ‘same’ work, but from a home computer. Myths of the abuse of home-work, some with substance in some cases, aligned ‘remotely’ working with working without adequate supervision and the ability to do other things, even other work, provided one’s home-based work-computer showed minimal engagement readings, but the interst of the work ‘remote’ in working ‘remotely’ lies in, when linked to work, an indirection in the doing of task that someone thinks of as work. In office ‘work’ that may be a dual indirectness. Here is the etymology:
remote (adj.): mid-15c., “distant in place, apart, removed, not near,” from Latin remotus “afar off, remote, distant in place,” past participle of removere “move back or away, take away, put out of view, subtract,” from re– “back, away” (see re-) + movere “to move” (from PIE root *meue- “to push away”). Related: Remotely; remoteness.
The meaning “distant” in any sense is from 1590s; by 1711 as “slight, inconsiderable” (of resemblances, chances, etc.). Remote control “fact of controlling from a distance” is recorded from 1904; as a device which allows this from 1920.
The idea that we move back and away from the office is useful to both opponents of remote working as a social practice and its adherents, since both find value in the ability, for the former as a means of arguing the case for the abuse of working duty it can involve oin their eyes, in the latter as a true realisation of labour-saving means of working and the cutting of surplus costs like travel time and price. But indirection and workare not cognate concepts with the term work as originally used and specifically of the ‘working’ classes.In a progressive society, the indirect relation of remote work in the office or at a remote space might be rejoiced in, but only if work was seen as a thing that joins us in duty and love of each other. Alasdair Gray cited another artist’s view of this about a nation in which work is not imposed on many by a few, in the latter’s interests alone: ‘

All my love
Steven xxxxx
_________________________________________
[1] Jeremy Seabrook (2013) ‘he language of labouring reveals its tortured roots’ In The Guardian (Mon 14 Jan 2013 21.30 GMT) Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/jan/14/language-labouring-reveals-tortured-roots1.